At first I didn't particularly care for the film because the I thought the lead character was very irritating and self-centered. I did not find him charming in any way and couldn't really believe anyone could be attracted to him.
I have since grown to understand that that is kind of the point. As was the case with Thora Birch's Enid character in GHOST WORLD. Max is not meant to be endearing, he is meant to be real. The film forces us to get caught up in the life of a character who isn't just a pretty boy (Freddie Prinze Jr.) spouting cute dialogue. He is frustrated, and he lashes out with biting humor.
Also, his ambitious stage productions really hit home with me. I once did a play that had a huge musical vietnam sequence complete with gunfire, dancing prostitutes...the works. I wanted to make a movie and instead put on an elaborate play that felt more like a movie.
Bill Murray is also wonderful in the film. He's the perfect foil for the film.
I've only seen RUSHMORE once. But it has stayed with me. Can't wait to finally get my hands on the Criterion DVD.
