|
From reading a lot of these posts, it appears that there are some strong and lengthy opinions on this subject which is great. I won't get into too much depth other than to say this...
For one, I really think that judging the movie on its own merit is completely warranted, rather than comparing it to the book....I will say, that by not reading the book, I can do so easier, but really we are focusing on the movie I think, the book vs. the movie is not of great interest to me. Not that I haven't read and don't respect the posted opinions.
After watching the movie for the first time in the theater, I left with a bit of a confused feeling, but after owining the DVD, I have given Fight Club repeated viewings which has deepened my experience and understanding of the intent of the story and movie which has been rewarding. This is a movie that gets better with repeat viewings, so I would encourage taking that opportunity for those that have seen it once and might not want to see it again....but to each his own.
The direction was great from the set design to clothing, to colors and the kind of "rage against the machine" theme. The fighting also added entertainment and humor...think of the picking a fight with a stranger task. The ending with the music coming on and the quick penis shot was also comedy....a job beyond well done.
|