Complete newbie here, hope this doesn't sound pathetic after all the great discussion of this film on this thread, but I just wanted to add my opinion.
I am not a film student or pseudo-anything when it comes to movies.
I like many different kinds of films from many different genres, probably like most of you.
I saw Casablanca for the first time last winter, with a person who had never seen it before either. The dialogue sounded a little dated at first, but it flowed so smoothly we didn't even notice after a few minutes.
Bogart was perfect-(I had just seen Treasure of the Sierra Madre the week before and was finding it hard to believe Bogey was such a good actor. I was wrong. He was a great actor.)
And the smartly paced story draws you right in, if you pay attention and have any sense of history.(well, hollywood history)
The supporting players all seem very well cast, and do a superb job.
Peter Lorre is great to watch, I think.
I guess that's it. I can understand how some people might not like this one the first time through,(heck, I could easily see myself not liking this just a frew years ago) all I can say is try it again when you're in the mood for a great story, it will not dissappoint.
Bottom line:
I like it!
