Quote:
|
Originally Posted by tomdkat
Well, if I understand it correctly, she would have had to be completely nude to have followed the comics and it sounds like she would have been willing to go topless and that's about it.
I'm saying you're assuming and speculating since you haven't provided any evidence supporting your assertion. My assertion is we can't draw any conclusions either way in this case since we don't have enough info. Piratehunter has provided a ton and it sounds like you don't trust her in the first article piratehunter linked to.
Or maybe you just wished it would have been taken. 
Peace... |
NOOO, what I AM saying is that RR would have wanted to stay as true to the material as possible and if in fact Alba WAS okay with going topless (compromising on the nudity / topless) as a director, he would have taken topless instead of nothing. Even though you seem to think PH is providing "proof" of a combined decision, from my perspective he is providing proof that in facts points to a lame excuse so that no one looks like a prude. Think about it...actress willing to go topless to make movie more authentic to source material vs. director making a decision to
not take that option. COME ON!
Sorry, articles with lame interviews and rationale only provide proof of covering the truth of why the decision was made...(previously stated WITH clarity in article) Non-nudity clause RULED the day!! (and the decision
)