[Titleist]

Well sorry it pisses you off, I wasn't saying that Tyler should be rail thin. She had gone on record saying that during LOTR she hit a healthy weight, and after LOTR she looked like she had let herself go. I've said more than a few times on this forum that I don't like overly skinny women, but rather healthy looking women. There's healthy and then there's a rapid weight gain that's not healthy.

Secondly I didn't say that Jersey Girl / One Night at McCools was her being fat, I'm referring to photos of her a year or two ago where she was looking dramatically bigger than she's ever been.

Obviously I phrased that idea in a fairly chauvinistic and mean way, I apologize on that front. But frankly these stars get paid millions of dollars for their looks, and don't take this the wrong way, but they put themselves out there to be judged. To be honest I don't really care to make a change to the social pressures of hollywood, it's a shitty system to be sure, but when actresses can make millions of dollars for winning the genetic lottery my sympathy for the pressures of ideal beauty is pretty low. I guess what I'm saying is that I support a woman's basic right to be appreciated for who they are in 99 percent of the jobs out there, but when they enter a business that's blatantly self aware of how vain it is I really stop caring.

I'm not trying to reduce your opinion of me, just stating my opinion. I was out on a walk earlier and started thinking about this thread, and yeah I do feel bad for how I phrased my original post, and in retrospect I probably wouldn't have written it, but I obviously did, so I'm just trying to stick to my guns here and defend my point. Again it was never to say she was always fat, but rather after being at a healthy weight she had gained a significant amount of weight.