Quote:
Originally Posted by ganthc
and how you interpret that to mean that vc-1 on the ps3 sucks. It's the "SLIGHTLY" smoother and cleaner part that belies the "not as good" part. It seems that you are overplaying the situation here, and maybe that's why Derb reacting like he did.
|
Please quote where I posted that the "VC-1 on the PS3 sucks." That is your statement, not mine.
Instead of pulling his quotes out of context by partially quoting him, lets see what Robert George said in full:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Robert George/Obi
Lo and behold, the excessive blocking I saw on the Blu-ray was nearly gone. I had to back up and look twice again just to see any blocking at all. While very close overall, the HD DVD played on the XA2 looks slightly smoother and cleaner while maintaining the same level of sharpness and detail as the Blu-ray disc played on the PS3.
I know these both these are the same transfer and same VC-1 encode, so I can only assume that all VC-1 decoders and players are not created equal.
|
As I've stated, that means exactly what I posted - the PS3 VC-1 decoder is not as good as the Toshiba's as per Obi.