Thread: The Hobbit
View Single Post
Old 12-20-2007, 11:42 AM   #41 (permalink)
Rileydog
Actor
 
Rileydog's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Simpsonville, SC, U.S.
true, and that could be filled in as parallel 'goings on' during the Hobbit to make 2 very solid films, but both titled Hobbit.

I only really know the novels, and not nearly as well as some other fans, and not much of the appendices or surrounding story that fills in some of the history. I did read a post about what could be covered regarding the necromancer hunt and the whole council meeting, chasing him, etc. But it just didnt feel like enough for a standalone movie.

But, if it was worked into the film as a side story, and even throw in the hunt for gollum after riddles in the dark, that could work.

Although I dont know the years and timeline of how they all fit together, but if anyone could do it, PJ could.

Are we going to open up a forum dedicated to this like the old LOTR / SW Forums, or maybe re-open the LOTR? I am sure there will be alot of speculation between now and 2010.
Rileydog is offline   Reply With Quote