Quote:
Originally Posted by No6PackJoe
I do like the idea of downloading movies I'm not sure I would watch more than once, (I too have shitloads I've only watched once or twice ), but I also want it to be the best presentation possible. The Apple TV would be appealing if it was a true 1080p presentation instead of 720p unconverted to 1080p.
|
I think the target filesize for HD downloads will likely be 4-7GB/each, at least for now. At that size, you can either have video encoded at 720p with little to no artifacting, or at 1080p with a lot of artifacting. Lower resolution with less artifacting is a better choice, IMO. 1080p without artifacts would be 8-15GB with much higher peak rates as well (killing streaming possibilities), which is unrealistic ATM.
In other words, I think you are doing a disservice for asking for "True 1080p" because by demanding this you will get an overall crappier picture due to artifacting, even though it might be higher resolution. 720p w/o artifacts upconverted to 1080p is a much more feasible choice and will have better picture quality for downloads in the end IMO.