First of all, you have set yourelf a budget. IMHO that is the biggest factor in deciding on what to buy. You can look for the features you want in your price range. If you are ever considering going to separates, like I am, don't look at amp power. My current, ever evolving plan, is to start adding amps. I was going to do that last month, but got the VP50 Pro instead. So, I pushed my amp aquisition back 6 months.
Here is what I am doing. I'll be using my AVR when I add amps as a controller. Then I'll replace my AVR with a THX Ultra controller later down the road. I'm just waiting for a higher end piece with HDMI Audio. The current crop, besides the Denon ( out of my price range, ) or the Onkyo don't do HDMI audio. I wanted to pick up the new B&K Ref 70, but it isn't slated for HDMI Audio, just video. Now, the new McIntosh will do it, but I can't afford it
I imagine there will be some new things coming up at CEDIA.
One thing I would like to see, is a piece from Denon between the 4308, and the 5308. Theold 48XX series would be perfect for MY application. Adding amps, two channels at a time, makes separates within my reach.
In closing, you know what you like. You know what you can afford. You know how soon you have to have it. Pioneer Elite, Denon, Marantz, and even Onkyo/Integra all have a good reputation. unfortunately, only you can say if you are going to be happy with your purchase. Opinions can help if you trust the source.
j