Rock Band

[Derb]

Originally Posted by umainebearman

Thats the truth, RB is better in every single way.

As far as your gripe with the HO/POs.... I haven't hand any trouble with the RB hammer ons and pull offs. As a matter of fact I hit more of the RB ho/po than I do or did in GH 2 or 3. Horizontal notes... not really sure what you mean by that one??

Sorry but no way is RB better at "gameplay" than GH3 with regard to guitar playing.

[umainebearman]

Better songs less distracting back grounds, better features for a group. DLC which contributes to the games longevity,which leads to more game play puts GH to shame. So yeah I'd say that the everything about RB over shadows Guitar Heros 1 trick pony. But of course thats my opinion. I suppose you could ask everyone else on here that has played both which is better.

[Derb]

Originally Posted by umainebearman

Better songs less distracting back grounds, better features for a group. DLC which contributes to the games longevity,which leads to more game play puts GH to shame. So yeah I'd say that the everything about RB over shadows Guitar Heros 1 trick pony. But of course thats my opinion. I suppose you could ask everyone else on here that has played both which is better.

Why? both have there pro's & con's

RB's con just so happens to be guitar. At first I didn't mind missing a few notes here or there cause the songs rock! Now that I have played for months now, I still miss notes because of the lame placement of Ho & Po's + the note bar is almost half the size of GH3 because they went horizontal instead of round. I might be coming off a bit strong on this issue but aside from that, it is a great game & a better multi-player game than GH for sure. No argument there from me. Same with DLC. I have downloaded 70+ songs already & plan to get more.

[1138]

I too have not touched GH3 in months. It's all RB. We played GH3 for about a month and then RB came out and it's been no play time for GH3 since.