Upconverting players: Toshi vs. Oppo vs. Price

[Iguana Man]

Ok, I know the Toshi HD players excel at upcon, and I know the Oppo's do as well. My neighbor needs a new CHEAP SD player that upcons well.

Can you list the cheapest Toshi and Oppo players in order of video quality so I can suggest the right one for my neighbor?

He will use HDMI or Component.

Thanks!

[Iguana Man]

Never mind. I just ordered the HD-A3 for 97 bucks shipped.

(I'm so impatient sometimes)

[plissken99]

You did the right thing. While the Oppo may do various tasks technically better, the output of Toshibas is far more satisfying. Colors looked downright washed out from the Oppo compared to the HDA1.

[Sehnzeleid]

Originally Posted by plissken99

Colors looked downright washed out from the Oppo compared to the HDA1.

Actually this is most likely because the A1 incorrectly displays DVDs in HD colorspace instead of SD colorspace.

[Pirate]

That new OPPO DV-983H is getting crazy good reviews.

Secrets of Home Theater and High Fidelity - Oppo Digital DV-983H DVD Player

[Iguana Man]

Originally Posted by Pirate

That new OPPO DV-983H is getting crazy good reviews.

Secrets of Home Theater and High Fidelity - Oppo Digital DV-983H DVD Player

"Crazy good reviews" For $400 I'd have never sold my neighbor on it but for us, this does look like the player to beat at the moment.

[Astrakan]

Originally Posted by Pirate

That new OPPO DV-983H is getting crazy good reviews.

Secrets of Home Theater and High Fidelity - Oppo Digital DV-983H DVD Player

Unless I'm missing something, that review didn't talk about the quality of the upconversion. It only mentioned that it did it. Since it's Oppo it probably means it's going to do it well, but I for one would be interested in a comparison to other lauded upconverters like the XA2.

KM

[Iguana Man]

Originally Posted by Astrakan

Unless I'm missing something, that review didn't talk about the quality of the upconversion. It only mentioned that it did it. Since it's Oppo it probably means it's going to do it well, but I for one would be interested in a comparison to other lauded upconverters like the XA2.

KM

That's a good point. I kinda assumed they meant it was great at upconversion based on their admiration of that ABT-102 chip.

[viperdream26]

The upconversion ability of the DV-983H with ABT will be comparable to HQV Reon, as featured in the Toshiba XA2, Samsung BDP-1200, & 875/905 receivers.

-DB.

[tomdkat]

Originally Posted by Astrakan

Unless I'm missing something, that review didn't talk about the quality of the upconversion. It only mentioned that it did it. Since it's Oppo it probably means it's going to do it well, but I for one would be interested in a comparison to other lauded upconverters like the XA2.

I don't know if the Secrets guys analyze HD video output quality yet. I know with the HD DVD and upconverting players they've tested, they've focused on the 480p output from the player.

Peace...